HOME
/
GLOSSARY
/
Fair Market Value Purchase Option

Fair Market Value Purchase Option

A fair market value purchase option is a clause in an equipment lease or vehicle lease that gives you the right, but not the obligation, to buy the leased asset at the end of the lease term for whatever its fair market value is at that time. You do not know the purchase price upfront. The price is determined at lease-end based on an independent appraisal or a formula defined in the lease agreement. This is the opposite of a fixed-price purchase option, where the buyout price is set the day you sign.

Fair market value options are standard in operating leases and equipment financing where the lessor wants to retain residual value exposure to the asset.

How the Option Price Is Determined at Lease-End

When your lease expires, the lessor obtains an appraisal of the asset's current worth. Some agreements define fair market value as the price a willing buyer and willing seller would agree to in an arm's-length transaction, with neither party under compulsion to act. Others use a specific third-party appraiser named in the lease or a standardized valuation guide for the asset class, such as Kelley Blue Book for vehicles or an industry publication for commercial equipment.

If you believe the appraised value is too high, most well-drafted leases give you a period to negotiate or dispute it, sometimes with binding arbitration as the resolution mechanism.

Why Lessors Prefer Fair Market Value Options

A lessor who grants a fixed-price purchase option locks in the future sale price on day one. If the asset holds its value better than expected, the lessee captures all of that upside by exercising the option below market. The lessor absorbs the loss.

A fair market value option eliminates that risk. The lessor retains upside on the residual value. If the equipment holds value well, you pay more to buy it. The lessor's residual value position is protected regardless of how asset markets evolve over the lease term.

Fair Market Value Option vs. Fixed-Price Purchase Option

Fair Market Value Option Fixed-Price Purchase Option
Buyout Price Set at lease-end based on appraised value Set at lease signing; known upfront
Residual Value Risk Lessor retains; lessee pays market rate Lessee retains; profits if asset holds value above the fixed price
Monthly Lease Payment Typically lower; lessor retains residual upside Typically higher; lessee receives the residual value benefit
Tax Classification Usually treated as an operating lease (off-balance-sheet in older GAAP) Often treated as a finance lease; asset and liability recorded
Best For Lessee uncertain whether they will want the asset at lease-end Lessee confident they will buy and want price certainty

Tax and Accounting Implications

The presence of a fair market value purchase option is one of the criteria that determines whether a lease qualifies as an operating lease or a finance lease under ASC 842, the lease accounting standard effective in the United States for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2018. If the option price is not a bargain, meaning the lessee is not reasonably certain to exercise it, the lease generally remains an operating lease for accounting purposes.

For tax purposes, the IRS looks at whether the lease is a true lease or a disguised purchase. A fair market value option at lease-end strongly supports true lease treatment, because neither party has entered into an agreement that makes purchase inevitable or economically compelled.

Sources

  • https://www.fasb.org/page/ShowPdf?path=ASU_2016-02.pdf
  • https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p550.pdf
About the Author
69f8467037b69a9d6ca86eee_69de3985682f83e6650eb2d4_Jan Strandberg
Jan Strandberg is the Founder and CEO of Acquire.Fi. He brings over a decade of experience scaling high-growth ventures in fintech and crypto.

Before founding Acquire.Fi, Jan was Co-Founder of YIELD App and the Head of Marketing at Paxful, where he played a central role in the business’s growth and profitability. Jan's strategic vision and sharp instinct for what drives sustainable growth in emerging markets have defined his career and turned early-stage platforms into category leaders.
Buy and sell secondaries
Trade SAFT, SAFE notes, locked tokens, and other digital assets in the public Secondaries and OTC marketplace
Acquire a frontier tech business
Browse our curated list of frontier tech businesses and projects available for acquisition; including revenue-generating crypto platforms, DeFi projects, and licensed financial organizations.