Give-Up: Parties and Example of a Give-Up Trade


Key Takeaways:

  • The Give-Up Trade is a type of securities transaction where the executing broker gives up credit for the trade execution to another broker or dealer, known as the contra-broker.
  • The parties involved in a Give-Up Trade includes the broker-dealer, introducing broker, and executing broker.
  • An example of a Give-Up Trade is when an introducing broker executes a trade for a client but lacks the necessary clearance. The introducing broker gives up the trade to another broker-dealer with the required clearance.

Are you looking for ways to expand your trading portfolio? Knowing about give-up trades can help you diversify and invest more intelligently. You'll learn the definition of a give-up trade and its parties, as well as a detailed example.

Definition of Give-Up Trade

In the world of finance, a Give-Up Trade is a type of transaction where a broker executes a financial trade on behalf of a client but later relinquishes all control of the trade to another broker or the client themselves. The purpose of a Give-Up Trade is to allow the client to benefit from the execution services of a particular broker, without having to manage the trade themselves. This trade can be executed in various financial markets but is most commonly seen in the foreign exchange market.

A Give-Up Trade involves three parties: the client, the executing broker, and the clearing broker. The executing broker executes the trade on behalf of the client, and the clearing broker then ensures that the trade is settled. The clearing broker also assumes liability for the trade in case of a default by the executing broker.

It is important to note that a Give-Up Trade may not be suitable for all clients and that there are potential risks involved, such as the possibility of the executing broker defaulting. Additionally, there may be fees associated with this type of trade.

In a true story, A high-frequency trading firm used artificial intelligence to execute a Give-Up trade on behalf of a client. The AI system monitored various market indicators and executed the trade, which resulted in a significant profit for the client. This demonstrates the potential benefits of using Give-Up trades in financial trading.

Parties involved in a Give-Up Trade

Ready to understand the players in a give-up trade? This section is ideal. Discover the details of each participant, their duties in a give-up trade, and how they influence the trade.

  • Broker-dealers
  • Introducing brokers
  • Executing brokers

all have a part to play in a give-up trade.


A market participant authorized to buy or sell securities and commodities on behalf of customers is a Broker-Dealer. The role of the Broker-Dealer involves executing trades, providing research and investment advice to clients, and offering other financial services. Broker-Dealers are regulated by the SEC or FINRA in the United States and must follow strict rules and regulations to ensure fair treatment of investors.

Broker-Dealers often facilitate Give-Up Trades between different parties. In a Give-Up Trade, one party executes an order but then "gives up" the transaction to be settled by another party, typically a prime broker. The prime broker then settles the trade with each client's account with minimal risk from counterparty default.

It should be noted that certain firms only offer brokerage services, while others exclusively provide proprietary trading and market making activities. A strong understanding of financial markets is crucial for these participants to navigate the everchanging landscape accurately.

According to Investopedia, Goldman Sachs is ranked as one of the largest broker-dealer firms globally based on revenue generation and client base.

Introducing Broker: Because even parties involved in a Give-Up Trade need someone to introduce them to the concept of giving up.

Introducing Broker

An introduction intermediary, in the trading world, connects potential clients with brokers and facilitates transactions. They help investors find suitable traders who match their requirements for buying and selling financial products. This helps in building trust between the investor and trader.

The Introducing agent serves as a middleman who connects investors directly to prime brokers. On behalf of investors, an introducing agent liaises with prime brokers to develop a relationship on favorable fees and commission rates for the client.

A few things that make introducing agents special are that they have strong communication skills; highly experienced in working with different parties involved in trades such as trade advisers, banks, executives, hedge funds, and other investment companies; strong work ethics combined with knowledge of industry norms enable them to provide exceptional services.

Investors need an introductory broker because it gives them access to additional trading tools such as margin loans, spot trading facilities. Since every transaction done by using this broker includes payment from all involved parties' commissions based on revenue sharing agreements both investors and traders can benefit significantly alike.

If you're a new investor, it's important not to miss out on the value that an Introducing Broker can bring into your life - accessing more options thanks to purchasing power leveraging or other higher yield strategies.

Executing broker: the middleman who helps you give up on making decisions and gives up their commission in the process.

Executing Broker

An individual or firm responsible for carrying out transactions on behalf of a client is known as the performing intermediary.

In Give-Up Trades, the executing broker is responsible for conducting transactions and completing paperwork necessary to ensure successful execution between two counterparties. They perform the entire trade cycle at a professional level by providing relevant market information, order execution, clearing, and settlement solutions.

An executing brokerage firm's work is facilitated by its set of skills in various trading solutions like portfolio management services, risk management policies, hedge funds operations, securities lending & financing, and algorithmic trading strategies. They ensure that transactions are executed with minimum slippage while following regulatory guidelines.

In addition to managing trades for their customers, executing brokers also engage in research activities that provide recommendations on possible investment opportunities. Brokerages may charge fees and commissions for their services depending on specific client requirements.

A well-known example of an executing broker is Goldman Sachs. This history-making company has become one of the most successful brokerage firms in financial history due to its expertise in a variety of areas such as IPOs (Intital Public Offering), Corporate Finance & Treasury Solutions which helps Investment bankers complete initial offerings whilst pooling funds from institutional investors from around the globe.

Who needs a high-risk game of Russian roulette when you can just do a Give-Up Trade and hope for the best?

Example of a Give-Up Trade

Understand the concept of give-up trading.

To illustrate, a scenario for a give-up trade.

Plus, explore the advantages and disadvantages.

These trades could have positive or negative outcomes.

Scenario of a Give-Up Trade

A Give-Up Trade scenario occurs when a trader wants to exit a position and opts to transfer the trade to another broker, who specializes in executing such trades. In return for this service, the trader may offer the other party compensation or a portion of the profit made from the trade. This type of transaction can benefit both parties by ensuring a smoother and faster exit from a position.

During a Give-Up Trade, responsibilities are divided between two parties: the executing broker and the clearing broker. The executing broker is responsible for finding buyers and sellers and arranging for best executions, while the clearing broker assumes responsibility for settling trades by transferring funds to or from its respective clients' accounts. A Give-Up Trade can be executed electronically or negotiated between brokers.

Unique details regarding Give-Up Trades include the fact that they are primarily utilized within institutional trading circles as opposed to individual traders. Additionally, it is often used in situations where an executing broker has better access to markets than a clearing broker.

Don't miss out on potentially profitable opportunities by avoiding Give-Up Trades due to lack of familiarity with this concept. Familiarize yourself with this technique through education offered by various online trading resources. Take action today to lessen risk exposure when exiting positions quickly.

Advantages and Disadvantages of a Give-Up Trade

A Comprehensive Look at Give-Up Trades: Benefits and Drawbacks

Give-up trades are popular among traders, brokers, and clients. They offer both advantages and disadvantages that must be taken into account before engaging in such trades.


  • Access to a wider range of investment options
  • Ability to get prompt execution on high-risk trades
  • Better pricing opportunities for larger trades
  • Greater specialization, expertise, and financial resources from a third-party broker


  • Increased fees from the added staff involved in executing the trade
  • The potential loss of control over the execution process or timing of the trade
  • Risks associated with the counterparty's solvency or financial stability
  • The possibility of hidden costs or charges arising after the transaction is complete.

Additionally, some unique details need consideration when examining give-up trades. It is crucial to ensure that both brokers are fully aware of each other's policies on fees and commissions. Also, it may be wise to obtain legal or regulatory advice if engaging in an extensive give-up trade.

Pro Tip: Before conducting a give-up trade, always ensure you understand all terms and conditions mentioned by the counterparties involved.

Five Facts About Give-Up Trades:

  • ✅ A give-up trade is when an executing broker trades on behalf of another broker, who then clears the trade. (Source: Investopedia)
  • ✅ Give-up trades involve three parties: the executing broker, the introducing broker, and the clearing broker. (Source: Eurex Exchange)
  • ✅ Give-up trades can be used to facilitate trades for clients who do not have direct access to certain markets or exchanges. (Source: CME Group)
  • ✅ The executing broker is responsible for executing the trade and obtaining the best price, while the clearing broker is responsible for settling the trade. (Source: Charles Schwab)
  • ✅ Give-up trades are subject to various regulations and must be reported to regulatory bodies. (Source: FINRA)

FAQs about Give-Up: Definition, Parties, And Example Of A Give-Up Trade

What is the definition of Give-Up in trading?

Give-Up is an arrangement in which a broker or clearing house facilitates the clearing of trades between buyers and sellers. It enables a third party to settle a transaction on behalf of market participants. In essence, the broker or clearing house steps in and acts as an intermediary to guarantee a successful trade between parties.

What are the parties involved in a Give-Up trade?

The parties in a Give-Up trade include:

  • The buyer, who seeks to purchase the security or commodity.
  • The seller, who is offering to sell the security or commodity.
  • The executing broker, who facilitates the trade between the buyer and seller.
  • The clearing broker, who acts as an intermediary to clear the trade.
  • The clearing house, who guarantees the settlement of the transaction.

Can you provide an example of a Give-Up trade?

For example, suppose there is a buyer who wants to purchase 1,000 shares of Company ABC, and there is a seller who is offering to sell 1,000 shares of Company ABC. The executing broker, Broker X, arranges the trade. However, Broker X usually does not have the necessary regulatory clearance or capital to guarantee successful settlement. Therefore, Broker X entails the help of a clearing broker, Broker Y, to clear the trade. Broker Y, in turn, works with a clearinghouse, which assumes the legal responsibility of guaranteeing the settlement of the trade. This process is known as a Give-Up trade.

What are the benefits of a Give-Up trade?

The benefits of a Give-Up trade include:

  • It streamlines the process of clearing trades between buyers and sellers and reduces operational risk.
  • It enables market participants to transact efficiently and effectively with one another.
  • It provides regulatory compliance assurance for all parties involved.
  • It facilitates cross-border transactions, as clearing brokers and clearinghouses can be located in different jurisdictions.

Are there any downsides to Give-Up trades?

Yes, there can be downsides to Give-Up trades, such as:

  • Increased costs due to the intermediary fees charged by clearing brokers and clearinghouses.
  • Potential delays in settlement, especially if there are discrepancies with the trade details.
  • Additional risk exposure, as settlement risk still exists, albeit reduced, in Give-Up trades.
  • The potential for disputes or miscommunications, as there are multiple parties involved in the trade.